"Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of Truth and Knowledge is shipwrecked by the laughter of the gods." Albert Einstein
I once worked for a director who was well-educated, strategically savvy and decisive. She initially appeared to be a confident and capable leader, comfortable engaging with C-suite executives and elected officials. However, she was often rude to subordinates, relied on intimidation and insisted on always being right. What I first thought was confidence was actually arrogance, which negatively affected my team and the organization.
Distinguishing confidence versus arrogance can be difficult in a professional setting. Although these personality traits may seem similar, they are indeed quite distinct. Recognizing how each affects the workplace enables managers and leaders to build high-performing, resilient teams and foster a positive workplace culture.
What is Confidence?
Confidence is trusting your expertise, skills and abilities, believing you can handle any challenge to achieve specific outcomes. Confidence strengthens with experience. Each time you surmount obstacles and break through limitations, you identify areas for improvement and become more comfortable developing new skills. You also deepen your understanding of the value of your contributions and feel less stressed in challenging situations. Over time, this accumulation of evidence reinforces a positive self-image, allowing you to trust yourself and project genuine confidence. Most people are drawn to this self-assuredness, and it can be easier to make professional and personal connections. Confident people are also more likely to ask for what they need and want, leading to higher self-esteem and greater productivity.
At work, confident people empower others, welcome constructive criticism and acknowledge their mistakes. Confidence appears in employees who rely on themselves to address challenges and take responsibility for the results of their work, whether positive or negative. Confident leaders and team members are engaged, assertive, collaborative and receptive to learning and feedback. They share ideas, recognize their strengths and those of others, and approach new projects and challenges with positivity and confidence. People with confidence command respect among colleagues and leadership.
Research shows that people accurately gauge confidence through non-verbal cues. For instance, confident individuals maintain steady eye contact, uphold good posture and move calmly with intention. Their open gestures, such as uncrossed arms and open palms, project assurance. They smile sincerely and speak clearly. Confident people use body language to create a composed, controlled presence that earns respect. Studies also demonstrate that perceptions of confidence and competence are closely linked. If someone’s body language seems less confident, observers often attribute it to a lack of competence.
What is Arrogance?
Arrogance is the belief in your superiority and entitlement to preferential treatment. It’s a delusion where people overestimate their strengths, underestimate their weaknesses and exaggerate their self-worth. Arrogant individuals often misjudge how others perceive them and have little or no appreciation for the value others bring to the table. Traits such as insecurity, lack of self-awareness or limited empathy can contribute to an inflated self-image. Additionally, an imbalance between positive feedback and constructive criticism, as well as poor workplace culture and values, can foster arrogance.
In the workplace, an exaggerated sense of self-worth and overconfidence can damage relationships. An arrogant supervisor may overpromise, underdeliver, and shift blame to subordinates or publicly criticize them to avoid accountability. Similarly, an arrogant coworker may dismiss colleagues’ feelings or claim credit for someone else’s work. Such behavior can create a hostile environment through rudeness, intimidation or insistence on being heard. For those who feel entitled, arrogance can prevent them from seeking help, hinder professional growth and obstruct high performance.
Arrogant individuals often avoid direct eye contact, appearing unwilling or too important to engage fully in conversation. Behaviors such as scanning the room, checking a phone or watch, or lifting the chin to look down at others can make people feel unworthy of their time and attention. Crossed arms, dismissive hand waves, eye rolling or raised eyebrows also convey arrogance and reduce approachability.
Learn to Be Confident Without Being Arrogant
Recognize the unique value you bring and identify areas where you excel. Focus on developing these strengths, and acknowledge the effort you have invested in achieving them. Build genuine confidence from your accomplishments, but avoid boasting. Let your actions and results demonstrate your abilities.
Avoid placing yourself above others, regardless of your achievements or position. Experience or skill in one area does not make you superior to everyone else. Recognize that everyone contributes value in different ways, and no one is more valuable in every aspect.
Remain open to others’ opinions, ideas and support. Avoid dismissing input, even if you feel confident in your knowledge. Listening and accepting guidance demonstrates humility. Confident individuals welcome feedback and advice, recognizing them as opportunities for growth. In this area, practice makes perfect and a great way to do just that is through the CPE course, Bridging Communication Gaps: How to Connect, Lead and Influence Others.
The Difference Between Confident and Arrogant Leaders
Confident and arrogant individuals differ in how they relate to others. Confidence serves as a tool for collaboration, while arrogance acts as a weapon for competition. Confidence is about assertiveness and individual responsibility, and arrogance is about power and control. These differences are especially evident among those who hold leadership roles.
Leaders who trust their intuition and decision-making communicate ideas and expectations clearly and respectfully, ensuring team alignment. They acknowledge when they don’t have all the answers and reassure their team they’ll find solutions together. Leaders who mistrust others and assume a superior attitude often avoid responsibility, micromanage their team members and behave condescendingly. Confident leaders encourage others to share their ideas and opinions, which builds trust and collective ownership. In contrast, arrogant leaders dismiss diverse perspectives, leading to poor collaboration and reduced innovation.
How Managers & Leaders Can Handle Arrogance
Unfortunately, arrogance is common in the workplace, and we’re all likely to encounter arrogant colleagues from time to time. However, you can address such behavior without compromising your boundaries or self-respect. The ability to work effectively with diverse, conflicting personality types is a fundamental characteristic of high-performing leaders and managers.
Set clear expectations for roles, responsibilities, communication and conduct. Some individuals may be unaware that their behavior is offensive. Before taking disciplinary action, ensure everyone understands the company culture and how their actions affect others. If tensions persist, consider a team conflict management course to improve cohesion and effectiveness.
Develop your emotional intelligence to gain insight into your team members’ personality traits and better understand their motivations. This knowledge also clarifies the distinction between arrogance and confidence, helping you support effective relationship management with various personality types. The more empathy and understanding you can extend, the more respect and acceptance of differences you can promote among your team, fostering harmony and driving high performance.
Practice the fine art of assertive communication when interacting with someone whose arrogance becomes aggressive. Expressing your needs and feelings directly, firmly and confidently goes a long way to reducing conflict and improving communication with arrogant people.
Confidence is vital to success, while arrogance undermines trust and productivity. Recognizing the difference and focusing on building confidence in yourself and your team helps foster a supportive and innovative work environment. Practicing self-awareness, empathy and humility allows you to inspire others and achieve lasting success without becoming arrogant.
Anne Evenson is a native Austinite and a proud Veteran’s spouse with over 20 years of marketing, communications and program coordination experience in the public, private and nonprofit sectors. She is also a sculptor, jeweler and all-around dabbler in the arts and loves to help military-connected individuals discover their inner creativity.
Learning and professional growth go hand in hand. For regular career insights and information on continuing education programs offered by UT’s Center for Professional Education, subscribe to our monthly e-newsletter, It’s Your Career.